Is Tesla a Buy? Analyzing the Recent Surge and Future Prospects

Key Takeaways

Recent Stock Surge: Tesla's stock has soared nearly 90% recently due to strong delivery numbers and analyst optimism.

Slowing Car Sales: Vehicle sales, making up 88% of Tesla's revenue, have declined, raising concerns.

Speculative Future Tech: Innovations like RoboTaxis and Tesla Bots offer potential but come with high risks and uncertainty

Tesla's stock has been on a wild ride, showing significant volatility over the past few months. After hitting a low at the end of April, Tesla's stock rebounded sharply, climbing nearly 90% in just over a month. This remarkable recovery has caught the attention of many investors, sparking a debate on whether Tesla is a buy right now.

The Recent Rally: What's Driving It?

The recent surge in Tesla’s stock price can be attributed to a few key factors:

Q2 2024 Delivery Numbers: Tesla delivered 445,000 vehicles in Q2 2024, slightly exceeding analysts' expectations of 439,000 units. Although this 1.3% beat might seem modest, it helped boost investor confidence.
Analyst Optimism: Following the delivery report, analysts from Bank of America and Wedbush Securities raised their price targets to $260 and $300, respectively. Their optimistic outlook on Tesla's potential significantly fueled the stock's rally.
Anticipation for RoboTaxi Day: One of the most exciting developments on the horizon for Tesla is the highly anticipated RoboTaxi day, initially scheduled for August 8th but now delayed until October. This event is expected to provide critical updates on Tesla's advancements in autonomous driving technology.

The Challenges: Slowing Car Sales

Despite the recent surge, Tesla faces notable challenges:

Decline in Car Sales: In Q1 2024, Tesla's revenue from vehicle sales dropped by 4.7% year-over-year, totaling $18.8 billion. This decline reflects broader concerns about slowing car sales, which account for 88% of Tesla's revenue.
Growth Projections: Tesla has cautioned that vehicle volume growth for this year might be significantly lower than the previous year, contributing to investor anxiety about the company's near-term performance.

Speculative Technology: A Double-Edged Sword

Tesla's future, however, is not just about car sales. The company is heavily invested in speculative technologies that could redefine its revenue streams:

RoboTaxis: Elon Musk has long promised a fleet of autonomous robo-taxis, which could revolutionize urban transportation. Musk envisions a scenario where Tesla owners can earn revenue by sending their cars out as automated Ubers. This concept, if realized, could open a significant new revenue stream for Tesla and its customers.

Tesla Bots: Another ambitious project is the Tesla Bot, also known as Optimus. Unveiled at the World AI Conference, this humanoid robot is designed to perform mundane tasks. Musk has claimed that Optimus will be ready by 2025 and could generate more revenue than Tesla's automotive business. While promising, these claims need to be met with a healthy dose of skepticism given Musk's track record of over-promising and under-delivering.

Elon Musk's Promises: A Reality Check

Elon Musk's visionary ideas often generate excitement and drive Tesla's stock price. However, his ambitious timelines frequently face delays. For instance, Musk has promised full self-driving (FSD) capabilities for years, yet true level 5 autonomy (where a car can drive itself under all conditions without human intervention) remains a distant goal. Most experts believe level 5 autonomy is several years away, and even level 4 (high automation under specific conditions) is challenging to achieve soon.

Conclusion: Is Tesla a Buy?

Investing in Tesla means betting on both its current vehicle business and its potential to innovate and lead in autonomous driving and robotics. The recent stock surge reflects optimism about these future technologies, but investors should remain cautious about the inherent risks.

For Growth Investors: Tesla's innovative edge and potential new revenue streams make it an attractive option, despite the volatility and ambitious promises.
For Cautious Investors: The slowing car sales and frequent delays in promised technologies suggest a more measured approach, waiting for clearer signs of sustainable growth.

In summary, Tesla remains a high-risk, high-reward investment. Those considering buying Tesla should weigh its speculative future prospects against the reality of its current financial performance and the inherent volatility of its stock.

Should you invest $1,000 in Tesla right now?

Before you buy stock in Tesla, consider this:

MyWallSt founder Emmet Savage and his team of analysts have been successfully picking stocks for more than 25 years and their favorites are crowned Stock of the Month.

MyWallSt’s Stock of the Month service has more than quadrupled the return of the S&P since 2018* and will provide you with all the guidance you need to confidently build a market-beating portfolio.

Shopify became Stock of the Month in January of 2017 and has since returned 1323%*.

Join MyWallSt Invest Plus to enjoy Stock of the Month and other great benefits like:

Ten Foundational Stocks to hold until 2034
A new stock pitch each week from 60k worldwide
A ranked library of 60+ international stocks

Check Out Stock of the Month

*As of May 2024