What Is A Better Investment: Clover Health or Teladoc?
We examine two healthcare stocks that were once Wall Street's darlings but have since fallen out of favor and ask, which is a better buy?
Aug. 2, 2021

The healthcare industry is ripe for disruption due to high costs and inefficiencies. These problems were further exacerbated with the onset of COVID-19, where the industry was ill-equipped to cope with the shift to digital and remote care. With a sizeable market opportunity and both companies attempting to disrupt the industry, we ask which company is a better investment?

Clover Health: Bull vs Bear Arguments:

Clover Health (NASDAQ: CLOV) is a Medicare Insurance provider that focuses primarily on the Medicare Advantage market. It was founded in 2014 before going public through a special purpose acquisition company (SPAC) in 2020, led by Chamath Palihapitiya. Its focus is on "creating great, sustainable healthcare to improve every life" through a combination of its proprietary technology Clover Assistant, data analytics, and preventative care.

In Q1 2021, Clover reported a record $200 million in revenue, increasing 21% year-over-year (YoY). Management is also guiding for revenue of $810 - $830 million for the full fiscal year. It also has a relatively strong cash position with $720 million and $278 million in debt. This cash should allow it to expand. 

Clover recently entered into the largest segment of Medicare known as Original Medicare, which has helped increase its lives under management to 130,000. There is also an aging population in the U.S. which will substantially increase the number of people eligible for Medicare in the coming years. Its Medicare Advantage members are set to reach 68,000-70,000 this year, a growth rate of 17%-21% YoY. Its members also like Clover, with a net promoter score of 63, which is well above the industry average.

However, Clover's losses continued to increase in the quarter from $28 million a year prior to $48 million in Q1 and are unlikely to change anytime soon. Furthermore, when the company was being brought public, management forecast 200,000 lives under contract by the end of 2021, but in Q1, it halved this, and not for the first time has management missed targets. 

There are a number of ongoing investigations into Clover and its directors following a scathing short report by Hindenburg Research. The short report made a wide range of allegations and is a cause for concern despite the company denying many of these. To read more about the short report, click on the link below.

Teladoc Health: Bull vs Bear Arguments:

Teladoc Health (NYSE: TDOC) is a telemedicine and virtual healthcare company that went public in 2015 and has produced returns of over 800% since its IPO despite the recent drop.

Teladoc estimates that the telehealth space will continue to accelerate at a compound annual growth rate of 38% in the next five years. There is also further opportunity outside its core offering with its Livongo merger, which increased its total addressable market to $121 billion. 

Teladoc reported another strong quarter of growth, with revenue rising by 109% YoY or 41% organically in Q2, 2021. It signed several new deals, and one such example is its new partnership with Healthcare Services Group, the fifth-largest health insurer in the U.S. Management also raised guidance for the fiscal year to $2.0-$2.025 billion.  

COVID-19 has accelerated the shift to digital care. Despite tough comparables from last year, telehealth visits increased to 3.5 million, rising 28% YoY with an increasing number from non-infectious diseases. The Livongo merger also means that Teladoc is no longer reliant on telehealth and has a full suite of offerings and new products such as myStrength for mental health offerings which was recently launched. The Livongo deal, if executed accordingly, should fuel long-term growth and is expected to create $500 million in synergies by 2025. 

Teladoc faces intense competition, particularly in the telehealth space from companies such as Amwell, newer entrants like Doximity, and companies such as OneMedical offering similar offerings for chronic conditions. 

Despite the history of executing acquisitions effectively, if Teladoc fails to do so with the Livongo merger, it will severely hurt the stock price. In the most recent quarter, the merger weighed on results with a wider net loss than expected of $133.8 million, and Teladoc still looks a long way off from turning a profit.

So, which stock is a better buy right now?

Teladoc appears to be better positioned to disrupt the healthcare industry. Unlike Clover, its financials are good, it's meeting targets and has not been the subject of a short report. The pullback in its share price also makes it an attractive investment today.

If you want to stay ahead of the curve and invest in growing industries such as telemedicine, MyWallSt's got you covered with a shortlist of market-beating stocks, so you too can accumulate long-term wealth. Simply click here for free access today.

MyWallSt operates a full disclosure policy. MyWallSt staff currently holds long positions in companies mentioned above. Read our full disclosure policy here.

Top Ten Stocks To Buy Now
Commit to your future wealth today and join 1000s of subscribers receiving:
  • New stock picked every week out of 60,000 worldwide
  • Ten Foundational stocks to hold until 2034
  • A library of 60 stocks with analysis
  • 10 year Track record of performance
By submitting your email address, you consent to us keeping you informed about updates to our website and about other products and services that we think might interest you. You can unsubscribe at any time. Please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

The Home of Successful Investing.

© 2024 MyWallSt Ltd. All rights reserved.







This website is operated by MyWallSt Ltd (“MyWallSt”). MyWallSt is a publisher and a technology platform, not a registered broker-dealer or registered investment adviser, and does not provide investment advice. All information provided by MyWallSt Limited is of a general nature for information and education purposes, and you should not construe any such information as investment advice. MyWallSt Limited does not take your specific needs, investment objectives or financial situation into consideration, and any investments mentioned may not be suitable for you. You should always carry out your own independent verification of facts and data before making any investment decisions, as we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information we publish and any opinions that we publish may be wrong and may change at any time without notice. If you are unsure of any investment decision you should seek a professional financial advisor. MyWallSt Limited is not a registered investment adviser and we do not provide regulated investment advice or recommendations. MyWallSt Limited is not regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. MyWallSt Limited may provide hyperlinks to web sites operated by third parties. Your use of third party web sites and content, including without limitation, your use of any information, data, advertising, products, or other materials on or available through such web sites, is at your own risk and is subject to the third parties' terms of use.